Grass Seed Test: The Final Installment!

Folks- it's prime time in the Northeast for overseeding and repairing your lawn from the summer drought. I started the seed trials over 3 weeks ago. Scotts, Pennington, and Pearl's Premium head to head. Each mix was seeded side by side in a patch of my yard that had been prepped with starter fertilizer and topsoil after being thoroughly raked. I watered daily and gave the seedings every bit of attention they might need.

Final results (and they did surprise me)

1) Scotts Landscaper's mix: The combination of Creeping Red Fescue and Perennial Ryegrass makes this one the winner. It germinated fast, filled in densely, and continues to grow at a steady rate.

2) Pennington Perennial Ryegrass Smart Seed: It's growing rapidly but not as dense as the Scotts. One negative, they coat the seeds with that annoying blue fertilizer spray. Your hands will be blue for a long time if you don't wear gloves. You have to wonder what the heck kind of chemicals are in that too!

3) Pearl's Premium (Sunny): Big price and little results. Yes- they do warn that the germination rate is much slower with the tall fescues but come on - over three weeks and a few single seedlings here and there. It was a major disappointment.

So for under $40 you can go to your local Lowes or Home Depot and get yourself some Scotts and have excellent results.

This isn't the end of the story.....I actually have to flashback to July to fill in the rest of my results and the full story. The reason I started this whole test process was because we found a unique patch of grass in our lawn that was thriving during the heat and drought we had here. All of the bluegrasses and some of the rye were dying off and crispy by mid July. This patch was bright green and super soft.

I started with a simple Google search (which later turned into days of googling grasses). I relate it to mattress shopping. After an hour of laying on beds, they all feel the same! Grass is one unique and interesting subject. I never knew how much science was behind it. By late August I still had not identified the grass so I decided to test some common seeds (in the mixes I bought). I was almost positive it was part of the Scotts mix because I did overseeding with it last year. Nope!

Today I took a field trip to Weston Nurseries in Hopkinton, MA. They have horticultural experts there and one of them (John), happens to be a turf-grass expert. I took a small plug of the grass (roots and all) to him and within 20 seconds her had it identified. Guess what....it's a weed! Before I go down that road, let me say this- it's very desirable and you can use it for lawns. It turned out to be Creeping Bentgrass. It's quite common on golf courses and can tolerate close mowing. It's super soft, grows very slowly, and is very dense. Sounds good to me!

So what's next? Do I weed my entire lawn with bentgrass? No, but I found an interesting option from nomowgrass.com (it's 100% bentgrass) and marketed as a 'no-mow' lawn product. Hmm. I'm going to get a small sample and seed some patches in the lawn to test it out.

As far as overseeding the rest of the lawn, I recommend a 100% fescue blend (maybe with a small amount of ryegrass (for soil stabilization). There are some more expensive blends out there that are all fescue that you can purchase. It is money well spent because the fescues are extremely drought tolerant and have deep root systems that will allow it to stay green all season and choke out weeds at the same time. The Scotts is a great all purpose seed but for problem areas I'll definitely be going with a 100% fescue mix.

You can even make your own mix on Super Seed Store.

Good luck and if you have questions don't hesitate to contact me. Over and out!